You need to be a member to see the full content

H 03 Rethinking Fish Consumption

Fish has been a staple in the human diet for centuries, often praised for its health benefits, such as providing a rich source of omega-3 fatty acids crucial for maintaining good heart health and brain function. However, recent evidence raises concerns about the safety, sustainability, and ethics of fish consumption, casting a shadow over this seemingly healthy food source.

Whether a certain food product carries health benefits or not depends on what it is replacing in your diet. In a typical Western diet, fish often replace red meat.

In that setting it provides a health benefit. It is better to eat fish than red meat, but it is much better to avoid animal protein at all. In low-income food-deficit countries, fish may be an important and necessary food and nutritional resource, but in a Western diet there are no needs nor health benefits of including fish.

In this article, we will explore the various reasons why fish are unhealthy for humans to eat compared to a whole-food plant-based diet. We will discuss the presence of harmful contaminants and parasites in fish, the environmental impact of commercial fishing, including damage caused by trawling, and biodiversity and animal welfare concerns. Additionally, we will present alternative sources of omega-3 fatty acids that offer a healthier and more environmentally friendly option.

Table of Content

H 03 Rethinking Fish Consumption

Harmful contaminants  in fish

One of the most alarming reasons to reconsider fish consumption is the presence of harmful contaminants. As our oceans become more polluted, fish absorb these pollutants and pass them on to humans when consumed. Some of the most common contaminants found in fish include:

  • Mercury: Fish, particularly those high on the food chain such as tuna and swordfish, can contain high levels of mercury, a potent neurotoxin that can cause serious health problems, including brain damage and developmental delays in children (1).
  • PCBs and Dioxins: Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and dioxins are industrial chemicals that have been banned in many countries due to their toxicity. However, they persist in the environment and accumulate in fish. Long-term exposure to these chemicals has been linked to cancer, reproductive problems, and immune system damage (2).
  • Pesticides: Runoff from agricultural areas can introduce pesticides into the ocean, which then accumulate in fish. Pesticides have been linked to various health problems, including cancer, birth defects, and neurological disorders (3).
  • Antibiotics: Many fish farms use antibiotics to prevent disease, leading to antibiotic-resistant bacteria and residues in the fish that can be harmful to humans (4).
Carnivores and omnivores have sharp claws for catching and tearing their prey. We have flat nails or hooves.

Parasites and TMAO

Other reasons to avoid fish in your diet are parasites.

Parasites: Raw or undercooked fish can contain parasites such as tapeworms and roundworms, which can cause serious health problems if ingested by humans.

Foods of animal-origin including salt-water fish contain dietary precursors to TMAO. TMAO is a newly discovered toxic compound that is produced by our gut bacteria from ingredients that come from foods of animal origin such as carnitine and choline.TMAO may promote inflammation, oxidative stress, and DNA damage – all conditions that increase your risk of developing chronic diseases.

H 03 Rethinking Fish Consumption

The environmental impact of commercial fishing

Commercial fishing, particularly trawling, has a significant impact on the environment. Trawling involves dragging large, heavy nets along the ocean floor, which leads to habitat destruction, the death of non-target species, and a decline in overall marine biodiversity.

The global demand for fish has also led to overfishing and depletion of fish stocks, threatening the livelihoods of millions of people who rely on the fishing industry for their income. Fish farming has its own set of problems, including pollution, habitat destruction and animal welfare issues.

Animal Welfare Concerns

H 03 Rethinking Fish Consumption

The crowded conditions in many fish farms can lead to stress, disease, and increased mortality rates among the fish. Moreover, farmed fish are often subjected to painful procedures, such as fin clipping and delousing, without the use of pain relief.

Commercial fishing methods like trawling not only harm the target species but also result in bycatch, the unintentional capture of non-target species such as dolphins, turtles, and seabirds. 

About 40% of fish caught worldwide is unintentionally caught and is partly thrown back into the sea, either dead or dying.

Alternative sources of  omega-3 fatty acids

But are there other ways to get the important omega-3 fatty acids, if we choose not to eat fish? For people without special dietary needs there are fortunately good plant-based sources of omega-3 fatty acids that can provide the necessary nutrients without the risks. By choosing those, we can help alleviate the pressure on fish populations, preserve marine biodiversity, and promote a more sustainable food system.

  • Algae: Fish do not produce their own omega-3 fatty acids. Instead, they get them from seaweed and algae. Algae-based omega-3 supplements are a sustainable and direct source of EPA and DHA, the most important types of omega-3 fatty acids. An adequate intake of omega-3 fatty acids is especially important during pregnancy, andhere is a supplement a good alternative to fish consumption by limiting the exposure to the harmful toxins found in fish. If you wish to take an algae-based EPA/DHA supplement, a daily dose of 250 mg of pollutant-free long-chain omega-3s (EPA/DHA), derived from yeast or algae, is recommended.
  • Flax seeds and chia seeds: Ground flax and chia seeds are excellent sources of ALA, a precursor to EPA and DHA. Just one tablespoon a day of ground flax seeds or chia seeds is enough to meet our daily needs  (as discussed in our film ‘Flaxseeds’).
  • Nuts – especially walnuts – are also a good source of omega-3. A handful of nuts a day is enough to meet our daily needs
H 03 Rethinking Fish Consumption

It is time to rethink our fish consumption. Currently, 34% of fish stocks are below sustainable levels, and nearly 60% are close to their maximum sustainable yield. If we want to preserve our oceans for future generations, we must start replacing fish with other, more sustainable sources of omega-3 fatty acids.

Making informed choices about our diet is empowering. It enables us to protect our health and the health of our planet and to live more happy, healthy and sustainable lives.

You need to be a member to see and take the test